By Layinka Ajibola
When President Bola Ahmed Tinubu declared on May 29, 2023, that fuel subsidy was gone, he set Nigeria on a new and controversial economic path. While the administration presented the decision as a necessary prescription to rescue public finances, eliminate waste and redirect resources towards national development, millions of Nigerians have had to contend with the harsh realities of higher petrol prices and an increasingly expensive cost of living.
More than three years after that declaration, the debate remains relevant: Was subsidy removal the right economic prescription, and, more importantly, are Nigerians beginning to experience the promised benefits?
To be fair, the government’s argument for removing fuel subsidy cannot be dismissed outright. For decades, the subsidy regime placed considerable pressure on public finances, encouraged opportunities for corruption and created distortions in the petroleum market. Maintaining an expensive system that was vulnerable to abuse while neglecting critical infrastructure was hardly a sustainable economic strategy.
However, a policy may be economically justifiable in principle and still become problematic through poor planning, inadequate implementation or insufficient protection for vulnerable citizens.
This is where the Tinubu administration must answer some difficult questions.
Consider the market trader who must now spend more transporting goods to the market, only to discover that customers can no longer afford the increased prices. Consider the civil servant whose monthly salary is increasingly consumed by transportation and food expenses. The commercial driver faces higher operating costs, while the farmer struggles with expensive transportation of produce, fertiliser and other agricultural inputs. Small-business owners, particularly those relying on petrol-powered generators, must contend with rising operating expenses that threaten their survival.
These are not merely economic statistics; they are everyday realities confronting Nigerian households and businesses.
The opposition has therefore not been unreasonable in questioning the timing, implementation and social consequences of subsidy removal. Nevertheless, criticism must go beyond political condemnation. Those advocating a return to the old arrangement must explain how it would be financed sustainably and how the corruption, inefficiencies and abuses associated with the previous system would be prevented.
Nigeria needs solutions, not merely competing political narratives.
First, the Federal Government must establish a transparent accountability framework showing how much has been saved through subsidy removal, how the additional revenue is distributed among the federal, state and local governments, and precisely how the money is spent. Nigerians deserve independently audited reports and measurable evidence of public benefits.
Second, government should strengthen targeted social protection. Cash transfers and other interventions must reach genuinely vulnerable households rather than become another avenue for political patronage. Assistance should be timely, adequate and independently monitored.
Third, investment in affordable mass transportation is urgently needed. Federal and state governments should expand public bus services, support more affordable intercity transportation and encourage cleaner, more economical alternatives to petrol-powered vehicles.
Fourth, domestic refining, agricultural productivity and reliable electricity supply must receive sustained attention. Stronger local refining capacity can improve petroleum supply security, while better rural roads, storage facilities and agricultural financing can reduce food distribution costs. Improved electricity supply would also reduce the dependence of small businesses on expensive generators.
Finally, workers’ purchasing power must be protected through realistic wage policies, improved employment opportunities and support for small enterprises.
The government must also recognise that additional revenue distributed to state and local governments comes with corresponding responsibilities. Governors and local government authorities must demonstrate how their increased allocations are improving roads, schools, hospitals and other essential services.
Ultimately, the success of subsidy removal should not be measured merely by the money government saves, but by the improvements Nigerians experience in their daily lives.
President Bola Ahmed Tinubu’s administration must demonstrate that the sacrifices demanded of citizens are producing tangible results. The opposition, meanwhile, must present credible and financially sustainable alternatives rather than simply capitalising on public frustration.
Nigeria does not necessarily need a return to an unsustainable subsidy regime, but neither can it afford economic reforms that disregard the welfare of its people.
*Layinka Ajibola, a Public Affairs Analyst, writes from Lagos, Nigeria.







